View source for Research:Judge/Quality

==Observations==
* Success rate increases with ad.ev.we bonus.
* Success rates differ significantly between weapons; in general, 'better' weapons are harder to judge.
* ad.ev.we bonus ''doesn't'' seem to make any real difference to the actual results for a successful judge - it only seems to affect chance of success and [[Research:Judge/Information thresholds|how much information is displayed]].
* There's zero variation in the overall quality and average damage characteristics (there's little variation in the ease-of-parrying stat too, but that's because it's maxing out at the top of its range).
* None of the scores for a given weapon seem to change much on average, even with significantly different skills (see the Tiger Fang results below).  This implies that anyone can judge a weapon, and the results would be valid for anyone else.
* Once you reach a JIR of 220 (can see speed of attack), all variance in results disappears - all your judges return the same (presumably accurate) result.

==Data==

The tables below show the raw data.  In each case:
* The data is the result of 50 judge attempts on the weapon.
* The overall quality score is derived from {{tl|wr-overall}}.
* The ease of use/parrying scores are derived from {{tl|wr-ease}}.
* The damage scores are derived from {{tl|wr-damage}}.
* A successful judge is one where you '''don't''' see 'but you're not sure' on the end of the first line.  Please only allow ''successful'' judges to contribute to the scores.

{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Long sword]]
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 249
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 88%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 10.0 || 11.0 || 15.0 || 5.9 || 3.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.9 || 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Long sword]]
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 293
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 98%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 10.0 || 11.0 || 15.0 || 6.1 || 3.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Tiger fang]]
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 249
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 58%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 13.0 || 12.7 || 14.8 || 8.1 || 5.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.7 || 0.4 || 0.7 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Tiger fang]]
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 293
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 88%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 13.0 || 12.9 || 14.7 || 8.1 || 5.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.5 || 0.8 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Tiger fang]]
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 293
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 298
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 226
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 90%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 13.0 || 13.0 || 14.8 || 8.1 || 5.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.4 || 0.8 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Katana (custom weapon)]] (light)
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 249
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 60%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 12.0 || 12.2 || 15.0 || 8.0 || 5.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Katana (custom weapon)]] (light)
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 293
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 96%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 12.0 || 12.0 || 15.0 || 7.9 || 5.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.9 || 0.0 || 0.9 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Wakizashi (custom weapon)]] (light)
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 249
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 98%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 10.0 || 11.0 || 13.0 || 4.0 || 4.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.8 || 0.9 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}
{|
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Weapon''' ||  [[Wakizashi (custom weapon)]] (light)
 |-
 | '''ad.ev.we bonus''' || 293
 |-
 | '''fi.me.x bonus''' || 403
 |-
 | '''fi.de.pa bonus''' || 312
 |-
 | '''fi.sp.ta bonus''' || 344
 |-
 | '''Success rate''' || 100%
 |}
{|class=wikitable | border=1 | style="float:left;"
 | '''Characteristic'''
 | '''Overall quality'''
 | '''Ease of use'''
 | '''Ease of parrying'''
 | '''Max damage'''
 | '''Average damage'''
 | '''Speed'''
 |-
 | '''Average score'''
 | 10.0 || 11.0 || 13.1 || 4.3 || 4.0 || ''Unknown''
 |-
 | '''Standard deviation'''
 | 0.0 || 0.8 || 0.8 || 0.8 || 0.0 || ''Unknown''
 |}
|}
{{-}}