Difference between revisions of "Judge Against: Swords"

From Discworld MUD Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
m
m (Protected "Judge Against: Swords": Vandalism target ([edit=autoconfirmed] (indefinite) [move=autoconfirmed] (indefinite)))
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
This is a research page intended to help us tighten up various weapon ratings. Basically, I'm just using "judge against" to compare various swords in the same rating range.  
+
This was a research page intended to help tighten up various weapon ratings with old [[judge]]. Basically, it used "judge against" to compare various swords in the same rating range.
  
This is an '''experimental research page''', and therefore the information presented here cannot be presumed accurate.
+
Since Judge works differently now, this can be updated with new information now that someone has high enough skills to compare reliably. All old information has been scrapped.
 
+
{| class="wikitable" border="1"
+
! Name
+
! Broad Rating
+
! JWB
+
! Presumed Rating
+
|-
+
| [[Rose-hilted long sword]]
+
| 95-100
+
| 263
+
| 96-100
+
|-
+
| [[Fine sabre]]
+
| 95-100
+
| 263
+
| 95-99
+
|-
+
| [[Short sword (custom weapon)]]
+
| 95-100
+
| 263
+
| 95-99
+
|-
+
| [[Fencing blade]]
+
| 95-100
+
| 263
+
| 95-99
+
|-
+
| [[Ruby-hilted rapier]]
+
| 86-95
+
| 263
+
| 87-95
+
|-
+
| [[Swept-hilt rapier]]
+
| 86-95
+
| 263
+
| 87-95
+
|-
+
| [[Rapier]]
+
| 86-95
+
| 263
+
| 87-95
+
|-
+
| [[Falcata]]
+
| 86-95
+
| 263
+
| 87-95
+
|-
+
| [[Falchion]]
+
| 86-95
+
| 263
+
| 86-94
+
|-
+
|}
+
  
 
'''Consistent "judge against" results ONLY'''<br>
 
'''Consistent "judge against" results ONLY'''<br>
"You think that the falchion is a bit worse than the falcata." @263<br>
+
Here are some judge comparison results at 21 strength. Some weapons that have the same judge results also compare the same for the most part but there are some that don't. I thought that they were all the same at first but the long sword vs rapier one isn't so so much for that theory :P.
"You think that the ruby-hilted rapier and the falcata are exactly the same." @263<br>
+
 
"You think that the fine sabre is a bit worse than the rose-hilted long sword." @216<br>
+
For reference, the "Slicey Thing" is a rose-hilted long sword and the "High Voltage Probe" is a custom katana (light version).
You think that the steel fencing blade and the bronze short sword are exactly the same. @216<br>
+
 
You think that the fine sabre and the bronze short sword are exactly the same. @216<br>
+
A wider variety of weapons that are close in ranges would be best for testing with I feel. There's not much to conclude from what results I have here. Some sort of chart would probably be nice. If someone wants, they can verify that the individual weapon ratings are correct using this info.
You think that the fine sabre and the steel fencing blade are exactly the same. @216<br>
+
--[[User:Baldarov|Baldarov]] 15:25, 8 September 2011 (UTC)
You think that the ruby-hilted rapier and the swept-hilt rapier are exactly the same. @263<br>
+
----
You think that the swept-hilt rapier and the rapier are exactly the same. @263 <br>
+
You think that the rapier is a bit better than Slicey Thing.
 +
Compared to Slicey Thing, the rapier is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals similar amounts of damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that the rapier is a bit worse than High Voltage Probe.
 +
Compared to High Voltage Probe, the rapier is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals less damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that the short sword is much better than High Voltage Probe.
 +
Compared to High Voltage Probe, the short sword is exactly the same on offense, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals more damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that the short sword is much better than Slicey Thing.
 +
Compared to Slicey Thing, the short sword is exactly the same on offense, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals more damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that the short sword is much better than the rapier.
 +
Compared to the rapier, the short sword is easier to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, exactly the same speed and deals more damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that Slicey Thing is worse than High Voltage Probe.
 +
Compared to High Voltage Probe, Slicey Thing is exactly the same on offense, exactly the same at parrying, exactly the same speed and deals less damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that Slicey Thing is better than the long sword.
 +
Compared to the long sword, Slicey Thing is easier to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, slower and deals more damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that the long sword is worse than High Voltage Probe.
 +
Compared to High Voltage Probe, the long sword is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals less damage.
 +
 
 +
You think that the long sword is significantly worse than the short sword.
 +
Compared to the short sword, the long sword is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, slower and deals less damage.
 +
 +
You think that the long sword is very much worse than the rapier.
 +
Compared to the rapier, the long sword is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, slower and deals less damage.

Latest revision as of 04:47, 1 June 2012

This was a research page intended to help tighten up various weapon ratings with old judge. Basically, it used "judge against" to compare various swords in the same rating range.

Since Judge works differently now, this can be updated with new information now that someone has high enough skills to compare reliably. All old information has been scrapped.

Consistent "judge against" results ONLY
Here are some judge comparison results at 21 strength. Some weapons that have the same judge results also compare the same for the most part but there are some that don't. I thought that they were all the same at first but the long sword vs rapier one isn't so so much for that theory :P.

For reference, the "Slicey Thing" is a rose-hilted long sword and the "High Voltage Probe" is a custom katana (light version).

A wider variety of weapons that are close in ranges would be best for testing with I feel. There's not much to conclude from what results I have here. Some sort of chart would probably be nice. If someone wants, they can verify that the individual weapon ratings are correct using this info. --Baldarov 15:25, 8 September 2011 (UTC)


You think that the rapier is a bit better than Slicey Thing. Compared to Slicey Thing, the rapier is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals similar amounts of damage.

You think that the rapier is a bit worse than High Voltage Probe. Compared to High Voltage Probe, the rapier is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals less damage.

You think that the short sword is much better than High Voltage Probe. Compared to High Voltage Probe, the short sword is exactly the same on offense, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals more damage.

You think that the short sword is much better than Slicey Thing. Compared to Slicey Thing, the short sword is exactly the same on offense, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals more damage.

You think that the short sword is much better than the rapier. Compared to the rapier, the short sword is easier to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, exactly the same speed and deals more damage.

You think that Slicey Thing is worse than High Voltage Probe. Compared to High Voltage Probe, Slicey Thing is exactly the same on offense, exactly the same at parrying, exactly the same speed and deals less damage.

You think that Slicey Thing is better than the long sword. Compared to the long sword, Slicey Thing is easier to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, slower and deals more damage.

You think that the long sword is worse than High Voltage Probe. Compared to High Voltage Probe, the long sword is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, faster and deals less damage.

You think that the long sword is significantly worse than the short sword. Compared to the short sword, the long sword is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, slower and deals less damage.

You think that the long sword is very much worse than the rapier. Compared to the rapier, the long sword is harder to attack with, exactly the same at parrying, slower and deals less damage.